Ancestry24 Answerit Careers24 Entertainment Fin24 Food24 GoTravel24 Health24 Kalahari.net Mobile News24 Play Property24 Sport24 Weather24 Wheels24 Women24

56 and loving it!

Cheryl tells us why she loves being 56...

Book it!

Visit our bookclub for great reviews and must-have books!
Zulu, Xhosa or Afrikaans?
Sbu thinks, in this time of xenophobia, we should look to our own language arrogances.
Article: Sbu Mpungose from women24
Not to be divisive in these times of xenophobia and the Zuma and Mbeki camp, but there is a popular belief that, much like Afrikaners, Zulu and Xhosa folk couldn't be bothered in engaging others in their mother tongue.

No one knows just yet who's worse between the 100% Zulus and the Xhosanistas – the accolade for arrogance is still being contested. But really though, when did Zulu and Xhosa become the lingua francas?

A generational thing...
Generations scriptwriters should get a golden star for effort. In recent times I've noticed how different characters in the soapie have expanded their vocab to speak a number of African languages, including Afrikaans.

For example, the lady-in-charge Karabo Moroka (Connie Ferguson) often greets and wars with S'busiso Dlomo (Menzi Ngubane) in smatterings of isiZulu. And not so long ago we were entertained by Grace's mother (Helene Lombard) when she delivered a plausible performance as a coloured woman from Cape Town who speaks Xhosa, Afrikaans and English. And even baddy Kenneth Mashaba (Seputla Sebogodi) has on a number of occasions dueled in Shaka's language and spoken lovingly in Verwoerd's .

There's just one snag – it seems the language stream is flowing one way.

If my memory serves me correctly, I've never heard characters whose main language is isiZulu, attempt to be multilingual. Why doesn't Gamla (Menzi Ngubane) attempt to say something civil or horrible to the other characters in their mother tongue, I've often wondered?

One of course could argue that it wouldn't be believable if say, a character like Khetiwe (Winnie Ntshaba) who started off as a farm girl from KZN were to suddenly wax lyric in sePedi. But, it wouldn't be a bad idea if Paul Mashaba (Siyabonga Twala), who has a Pedi brother in the make believe world, could actually utter a word in Pedi, instead of always communicating in isiZulu.

It does send a terrible message when all the Zulu speaking characters don't even attempt to converse in any of the other 10 official languages. It says that the Nguni tribe's lingo is more superior and that other languages enjoy an inferior status.

But to lay all of this on Generations' doorstep would be disingenuous. The problem is deeper – the soapie is merely imitating reality.

Repeat that in Zulu please
Have you ever noticed how, say, a Venda or Sotho is more likely to be multilingual? One might blame it on the Mfecane/Diaspora or that other tribes are much smaller, therefore the Ngunis (because of their sheer numbers) by default enjoy more space in the media and government platform.

My friend made an observation about her workplace; although there are equal number of Xhosa and Sotho speakers, the conversation (if not in English) is almost always conducted in isiZulu.

She had also observed how the Sothos at the office are more interested in other languages, while she felt this was not reciprocated. I've also noticed that if two Tswanas get into a taxi not knowing they were from the same clan, they were more likely to chat in isiZulu, even though they were both struggling to express themselves.

I'm also not without fault because, although I studied in Tshwane for four years, I rarely ever practice seTswana. I used to hide behind the fact that I was scared that people would laugh at me if I ever tried to string along a sentence in Sotho. My fear perhaps can be likened to the French who hardly speak any English lest they be ridiculed.

Whatever my reason, I don't think it's good enough. I'm no better than a white African that has his roots in this continent, yet he can't say dumela or Ndaa.

What do you think? How many languages do you speak, and which do you choose when at work or meeting people?


Ask an expert

Article Search

Get blogging

Women24.com Blogs allow you to overshare in a boundary-free environment! How cool is that?

Get one now!
Read one now!

Have something to say?
Your name
*email
Subject
Comment
This is so true S'bu, i am engaged to a Tswana guy and i am from Durban. I tell you, you don't want to hear us when we fight about language. I just started now speaking isiTswana although i mix it with isiPedi and Sotho. He bought me a book but trying to express yourself knowing that someone is going to laugh at you or ask to repeat - the fear is beyond me. All my life i've always been exposed to isiZulu and English, funny enough i speak more English than Zulu anyway. I sometimes wonder what happened to me. But i now i try to speak other languages even though i laugh at myself sometimes.
Sili on 20 May at 10:24

 

Interesting read.
Sandy on 20 May at 10:25

 

In my experience the "Afrikaner" is more likely to speak english than the english speaker to speak afrikaans. I agree that both are unlikely to be able to speak any of Sotho, Zulu or Xhosa (or any other language for that matter).
Mallencolly on 20 May at 10:27

 

I was half way through reading your artical and then realised it all sounds Greek to me.
Johann on 20 May at 10:38

 

I agree 100% with everything you have said in your article Sbu...I'm Pedi but I know 10 of all the other South African languages and I always have to be the one having to speak isiZulu and Xhosa or even seTswana for that matter, with other people. Maybe I should just speak sePedi and see what the response will be.
Liggy on 20 May at 10:41

 

Of all the African laguages, ndebele speaking people are the last people who would speak their own language, hence this lingo is dying. I feel that people should be proud of their mother tongue.
Bridget on 20 May at 10:46

 

but you nearly lost it by the Generations references - too much to remember etc.
Mxhosakazi on 20 May at 10:46

 

Sorry man, Sbu should have used a 7 De Laan example instead of Generations, apologies man.
Ace on 20 May at 10:49

 

DID YOU NOTICE THAT SABC SPORT(FOOTBALL) THICK THAT WE ARE ALL ZULUS?....DISGUSTING!
vincent on 20 May at 10:55

 

I am of Indian descent but can't speak a word of Hindi - small chance that i will find the time to learn an african language - easier for everyone to improve their English than for an english speaking person to learn an african language - which one of the many african languages should we then take the time to learn ? I live in the eastern cape so xhosa would be an obvious choice - but what if I was to relocate to Kwazulu Natal ?
Zacky on 20 May at 10:56

 


 
My Women24
Chick blogs... Here's where 24.women get talking.
3 Months!
Caprice is counting down the days until she gets married.