News24.com  |   OLX  |   PriceCheck  |   Property24  |   Kalahari.com  |   Careers24
 
Women24 - Your voice, every day
What irritates you at work?

In response to our article on #Officepetpeeves, our readers weigh in. Read their hilarious but true comments!

Sweet Brown gets a reality show

The Youtube sensation went viral, and now she’s planning to make appearances on our TV and movie screens! We think we’ve got time for that!

Women24 in your Inbox!
Sign up for our newsletters
  • Hidden tab for homepage
  • Love & Sex
  • Wellness
  • Fashion & Beauty
  • Bride24
  • Work & Money
  • Parenting
  • Books & Astrology
  • Home & Away
  • TV & Gossip
  • Chat & Win
 
Sex and Sizzle  |  Love and Marriage  |  Singles and Dating  |  Gay  |  Experts
Body and Spirit  |  Cartoons  |  Diet  |  Women's Health  |  Holistic Health  |  Sport  |  Green  |  Experts  |  Love your Body
News & Trends  |  Galleries  |  Celeb Style  |  Beauty  |  Reader Style  |  Experts  |  Great Hair
Wedding Planning  |  Bridal Fashion  |  Beauty  |  Travel  |  Bride24 Directory  |  My Wedding  |  Experts  |  Tools  |  Love Forever
At Work  |  Money  |  Legal  |  Technology  |  Experts
Falling Pregnant   |  Being Pregnant   |  Birth  |  0-12 Months  |  1-3 Years  |  School  |  Health & Nutrition  |  Galleries  |  Experts  |  Forums
Book Club  |  Astrology  |  News
News & Trends   |  Decor  |  DIY  |  Handcraft  |  Gardening  |  Food  |  Restaurants  |  Motoring  |  Travel  |  Experts
Celeb Gossip  |  Soapbox  |  Hotties  |  Series Addicts
Forums  |  Columnists  |  Letters  |  Blogs  |  Competitions  |  Giveaways  |  Games

Is this woman too fat?

Pin it Share

The overwhelming response to pictures of this plus-size model triggered a weighty debate not too long ago. What do you think... Is she too fat?

Woman smiling in tank top
Article: Meagan Karstens

Related Links

  • The skinny on size zero women
  • Looking good, feeling lovely?
  • Broken heart? Cut the fat.

The exclusion of size zero models from major catwalks was lauded as a breakthrough in the ongoing mêlée against eating disorders.

Plus-size model Lizzie Miller who posed semi-naked for a page 194 feature in the US edition of Glamour magazine has brought the contentious debate back into the limelight.

Why, you may ask?

The 20-year-old US size 12-14 model is considered 'too large' to represent plus-sized women.

By whose standards? We don't even know.

"It's sad," she says, "in the industry anything over size six is considered a plus-size."

Cindi Leive, editor of the magazine in question comes to Miller's defense, however, saying that the response to the photo has been positively overwhelming. "It's a photo that measures all of three by three inches, but the letters about it started to flood my inbox literally the day Glamour hit newsstands."


The picture, illustrating a story which touches on the issue of confidence, poise and being comfortable with one's body, is bound – quite literally – with ads and fashion shots depicting waif-like models.  If we were completely honest with ourselves, such images propagate a false ideal amongst women, men and teenagers alike.

Who is to blame?

Last year we reported about how fashion prodigy Alexandra Shulman, lashed out at some of the world's leading designers for forcing seriously skinny models into glossy magazines despite the outcry over bulimia and anorexia.

The chorus of disapproval is far and wide and in spite of being rejected by plus-size fashion houses such as Marina Rinaldi and Elena Miro (who prefer their models  between sizes 8 and 10), Miller is confident that the recent response to her photo "shows that the world is hungry to see pictures of normal women."

Is this true?

Would you like to see more normal, 'plus-sized' women representing our fashion lines? And more importantly, what are your thoughts on society and the fact that 20-year-old Miller is considered too fat?

Don't be shy,
tell us what you think…

 

- Women24

Read more on: diet  |  overweight  |  health

Share this page (What are these?):
  • Twitter
  • Yahoo
  • Google
  • Digg
  • del.icio.us
  • Facebook

Other Stories in Diet...

Stop hating on their weight
Stop hating on their weight

‘You have no right to judge Kim Kardashian and Kate Middleton If you don’t know them.’

How I chose life over death
How I chose life over death

Reader Nicolene Botha shares her story of how she got into shape by looking after her health.

24.com publishes all comments posted on articles provided that they adhere to our Comments Policy. Should you wish to report a comment for editorial review, please do so by clicking the 'Report Comment' button to the right of each comment.

Comment on this story
228 comments
Add your comment
Thank you, your comment has been submitted.
avatar
Logout
Comment 0 characters remaining
We reserve the right to maintain the quality of the discourse on the comments board as much as we can.
By posting comments you agree to our Terms & Conditions.
avatar
Logout
Comment 0 characters remaining
Loading comments... Loading comments...
  • Horoscopes
  • Cartoons
  • Soapies
Aquarius
Aquarius

Love related matters come under the spotlight for you today and someone close to you seems to be...read more

Aries
Aries

The sun moves into clever Gemini today and highlights the area of your horoscope that deals with...read more

Cancer
Cancer

It is a good idea to plan for some solitary time today. With the usual hustle and bustle of everyday...read more

Capricorn
Capricorn

Even though your work is never too far away from your mind, today you seem to be quite absorbed in...read more

Gemini
Gemini

The bringer of life, the sun, moves into your sign today, which also means that you’ll soon have a...read more

Leo
Leo

Your planet, the sun, moves into Gemini today and highlights the social connections you have with...read more

Libra
Libra

Travel and/or travelling plans are a focal point for you today. If you’re pining for the company of...read more

Pisces
Pisces

The changing of the sun from Taurus into Gemini highlights some of your family and domestic needs....read more

Sagittarius
Sagittarius

The sun shines ever so brightly on your love horoscope today and this would be a fabulous time to...read more

Scorpio
Scorpio

Today the sun moves into that sector of your horoscope which relates to what is shared between two...read more

Taurus
Taurus

You could find yourself pre-occupied with the value of your assets, particularly your home today. It...read more

Virgo
Virgo

A career matter is highlighted for you today and perhaps you need to take some time out to consider...read more

Bring You Down
Bring You Down

When do you feel like the world is working to bring you down? ...read more

7de Laan 13 - 24 May

Vanessa’s getting suspicious about Xander’s strange behaviour, and Ryno and Marcel have their first...read more

  • Most Read
  • Most Commented
  • Billboard Music Awards Worst Dressed
  • Confessions of a curvy girl
  • 10 Worst travel mistakes
  • Jullianne Moore’s epic shoe fail
  • Trevor & Haneli’s wedding
  • Confessions of a curvy girl
  • I don’t want kids of my own
  • The babification of Brave
  • Life before boobs
  • Best erotic books to read

Green Directories

  • Green Awareness

  • EcoFriendly Shop

  • Vermiculture

  • Freecycle

  • MakeCompost

  • Recycle

  • Travel Green

Heard on the Blogs...

Once an abuser always an abuser

Hope believes that it's imperative that all women should watch out for signs of abuse in a relationship.
Read her latest post here.

View all Women24 Blogs

Sponsored links

Quality lenses at great prices, only at Spec-Savers   Col’Cacchio Celebrity Chef Series 2013
1Life   Win with Mr Price Home
Win 1 of 10 iPhone 5s   Selfmed Med Aid

Jobs - Find your dream job

Recruitment Consultant

Midrand
Communicate Cape Town IT
R180000 - R600000

Recruitment Consultant

Centurion
Communicate Cape Town IT
Market Related

Intermediate Business Analyst

Johannesburg CBD
Communicate Cape Town IT
Market Related

Browse more jobs...
  • Free State Jobs
  • Kimberley Jobs
  • Mafikeng Jobs
  • Insurance Jobs
  • Media Jobs
  • Manufacturing Jobs
Register your CV...
Advertise a position
Job alert e-mails...

Property - Find a new home

HOUSES FOR SALE IN St Francis Bay, Santareme

HousesR 4 750 000

HOUSES FOR SALE IN Edenvale, Greenstone Hill

HousesR 3 700 000

HOUSES FOR SALE IN Paarl, Boschenmeer Golf & Country Est

HousesR 5 150 000

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Winchester Mansions

Spend 3 nights at Winchester Mansions from R3 330 per person sharing and pay for 2 nights. Includes accommodation, return flights, car rental and Local Travel Insurance.

Book now!

Kalahari.com - shop online today

Hot and exclusive Coby 7" wifi tablet – only R1299.95

Don’t miss out on this super hot deal of the week, save R300 on the Coby 7” tablet! Dispatched within 24hrs + free delivery. While stocks last. Buy now!

Nora Robert’s new novel Whiskey Beach

They accused you of murder. You proved your innocence. But someone doesn't believe you. Lose yourself in Nora Roberts' new novel Whiskey Beach. Buy now!

Up to 20% off all the hottest gaming pre-orders!

Get it while it’s hot! Save up to 20% on the hottest games on pre-orders including Grand Theft Auto 5, Fifa 14, Grid 2, Battlefield 4 and more. Pre-order now!

20% off the latest music releases

Get 20% off hot new music releases, including To Be Loved by Michael Buble, Now 63, The 20/20 Experience by Justine Timberlake and many more. Offer valid while stocks last. Shop now!

Robo Fish – the must-have pet

Robo Fish is the hottest new toy! It magically turns on when placed underwater and swims. Get yours now and watch your fish come to life. SO life like the cat won’t be able to tell the difference. Pre-order now!
Follow Women24
Women24:
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Advertise
  • Contact us
Digital Media & Marketing Association

© 2013 24.com. All rights reserved.
There are new stories on the homepage. Click here to see them.