24games Ancestry24 Answerit Blueworld Careers24 Channel24 Fin24 Food24 GoTravel24 Health24 Kalahari.net Mobile My Account News24 Nuus24 Parent24 Property24 Spaces Sport24 Weather24 Wheels24 Women24

Book du jour

Book on every best seller list? Please don't try to shove it down Adele Hamilton's throat.

"You MUST read Shantaram," said my friend Jess, her eyes shining with excitement.

"Ja," I replied. "I know."

In fact, Jess was the fifth person to recommend it to me in the space of a month. What I couldn't tell her was that her very enthusiasm and the passion of her description was a turn-off for me.

I get like this sometimes with books everyone loves. It took me three years to read Spud after everyone else had (good, wasn't it!), and The Kite Runner is still sitting there glaring at me from the bookshelf.

From time to time I give in and read the damn thing, and it's not often as thrilling an experience as the general buzz would make one hope. Life of Pi was great after I got past the first boring bits, but I really didn't think The Shadow of the Wind was THAT brilliant, although it was an enjoyable read.

I draw the line at The Secret, so perhaps it really would change my life... I will never know.

Sometimes I suspect people haven't really read the thing when they're waxing so lyrical about how brilliant it is (not you, Jess). I would much rather someone calmly gives me a less hyped book to read, because they honestly liked it and hope I might too.

Books are such a personal thing, I suppose that's what my resistance is all about. I don't want to feel pressure to read a book NOW just because everyone else is. Yes, it is an odd characteristic in someone who spends their time telling other people what I think of books and expecting them to listen. I see the irony.

My resolution this holiday is to give
Shantaram a fair shake and not hold its over-hyped status against it. As for The Kite Runner.. not yet.

Are you usually the first to read the book du jour? Or do you wait for the hype to blow over before you start reading the book?

 

- Women24

Read more on: book club  |  adele hamilton  |  reads  |  books
Share this page (What are these?):

Comment on this story


fiona 2/11/2010 12:00:33 PM
Just finished Shantaram. Don't bother with it, rather read Kite Runner.
karima 2/11/2010 1:05:04 PM
I agree wholeheartedly with your views! It's great when books are recommended but beware the "recommender!" I try to avoid books & movies sometimes recommended by talk show hosts. Do they get kickbacks, condisering some of the rot they glorify?
Suki 2/11/2010 2:05:53 PM
I completely agree - I hate being told what to do, so everyone punting an overhyped book (or movie, or even fashion accessory!) puts me off. I absolutely refuse to read something just because "everyone else liked it". The Twilight saga springs to mind, although I did read the first couple of pages and then put it down in disgust at the bad prose. I'd much rather choose my own books or borrow from friends whose judgement i trust. Glowing reviews are a little suspect, especially when I know the person in question doesn't share my love of characterisation above intellectualism.
Your name
*
Email
*
Comment
*
Please enter the text below
Captcha
 
 
Aquarius

That project just about seems to be in the bag, but until such time that you know it is, you’ll have...read more

Daily Hannah: 08 March - 12 March
Daily Hannah: 08 March - 12 March

Hannah wears a helmet when travelling through the passage of time....read more

The Bold: 12 - 26 March

Eric is blindsided by Thorne, tension escalates between the Logan and Forrester families, Katie...read more

Numerology

The key to your destiny. There is an incredible amount of information hidden within your name and birthdate.

Tarot reading

Life, Love and relationships. Get your free reading today.

I Heart New York

I hearth New York cover

W24 Price: Now R91.96

Angela Clark thought she was living her dreams until she found her fiancé shagging another woman.

Astro Love Match

with Petra du Preez

  • I'm a
  • and I like a

Want to know more?

Buy your compatibility profile here

Heard on the Blogs...

Need a good book to read?

Women24 Ed has put a list of books together for you to try.
See more here

View all Women24 Blogs

Women24 book club newsletter

Sign up for our newsletter and win a case of Perdeberg wine and a box of books from Kalahari

Jobs - Find your dream job

Teller

Gauteng
First National Bank

Department Head - Treasury

Gauteng
Bridgena Barnard Personnel Group

Senior Finance Manager: CA(SA)

Gauteng - Johannesburg
Network Recruitment CA- Centurion
R700,000-990,000 Per Annum Cost To Company

Cars - Search 1000's of new and used cars

AUDI

A4 3.0 Cabriolet Multitronic
2003
R 194,999.00

VOLKSWAGEN

Polo 1.9 TDi Highline 5-dr Dsl
2005
R 109,990.00

OPEL

Meriva 1.7 CDTi Enjoy MPV Dsl
2005
R 110,899.00

Property - Find a new home

ASSAGAY

Single Residential - House R 7 500 000

GORDONS BAY

Single Residential - House R 11 500 000

FANCOURT GARDENS

R 4 100 000

Travel - Look, Book, Go!

Free Games - TOO MUCH NEWS? TAKE A BREAK!

Kalahari.net - shop online today

The Widows of Eastwick

More than three decades have passed since the events described in The Witches of Eastwick

Fossil AM4019

Stainless steel (White mother of pearl), Quartz, Date function, 100m Water Resistant

Dell Mini 10 Pink Netbook with 3G

It may be small, but you’ll be surprised by all the fun features packed inside.

Kenwood 1,5lt Coffee Maker

Makes up to 12 cups of coffee

Bake

The title is divided into six sweet and savoury sections and includes recipes for biscuits to fill up the cookie jar.